swadhin / opencodehub public

Reconcile feature audit with latest implementation work

swadhinbiswas committed 8 months ago
aea2e5e
1 parent baf3b91
commit aea2e5e
2 files changed
+58 -51
Showing 2 changed files+58-51
doc/feature_audit.mddoc/missing_implementation_tracker.md
▼doc/feature_audit.md
+51-51
@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
1
1
# OpenCodeHub Feature Audit & Implementation Plan
2
2
**Audit Date:** February 6, 2026
3
3
**Total Features Analyzed:** 122
4
-**Status:** ✅ Implemented: 47 | ⚠️ Partial: 29 | ❌ Missing: 46
4
+**Status:** Reconciliation in progress (the February 6, 2026 aggregate counts are outdated after subsequent implementations).
5
5
6
6
## Feature Matrix Summary
7
7
@@ -35,7 +35,7 @@
35
35
| Branch protection rules | ✅ | Schema + UI + API in place |
36
36
| Repository templates | ⚠️ | Not fully implemented |
37
37
| Repository Wiki | ✅ | Implemented (Phase 8) |
38
-| File-level permissions | ❌ | Not implemented |
38
+| File-level permissions | ⚠️ | Path-scoped enforcement now covers PR comment create/edit/delete and batch-review comment submission; broader endpoint coverage remains |
39
39
| Commit signing (GPG) | ✅ | GPG key management UI exists |
40
40
| Commit signing (SSH) | ✅ | SSH key management UI exists |
41
41
@@ -48,41 +48,41 @@
48
48
| Stack rebase & auto-update | ⚠️ | Partial - manual rebase exists |
49
49
| Stack-level approvals | ⚠️ | Basic - individual PR approvals only |
50
50
| Bulk merge (merge stacks) | ⚠️ | Via merge queue, not explicit bulk action |
51
-| Custom PR states | ❌ | Only standard states (open/closed/merged/draft) |
52
-| Required reviewers per state | ❌ | Not implemented |
51
+| Custom PR states | ⚠️ | Schema exists (`pr-states`), end-to-end workflow adoption is incomplete |
52
+| Required reviewers per state | ⚠️ | Basic reviewer requirements exist; full state-specific enforcement remains incomplete |
53
53
| PR merge queues | ✅ | `merge-queue.ts` (590+ lines) |
54
54
| Conflict detection before merge | ✅ | `mergeable` field in PR schema |
55
55
| Auto-merge rules | ⚠️ | Basic via automations, incomplete |
56
56
| Draft PRs | ✅ | Schema supports `isDraft` field |
57
57
| PR labels | ✅ | Full implementation with schema |
58
58
| PR assignees | ✅ | Full implementation with schema |
59
-| PR checks | ❌ | Schema exists, CI integration incomplete |
59
+| PR checks | ⚠️ | Basic checks exist, but full CI provider parity is incomplete |
60
60
61
61
## 3. Code Review
62
62
| Feature | Status | Implementation Notes |
63
63
| :--- | :---: | :--- |
64
64
| Inline code comments | ✅ | `pullRequestComments` schema with line/position |
65
65
| Threaded discussions | ✅ | Reply threading via `replyToId` |
66
-| Suggested changes | ❌ | Not implemented |
67
-| Batch comments | ⚠️ | Schema supports, UI may be incomplete |
68
-| Code owner enforcement | ⚠️ | TODO in `automations.ts`, CODEOWNERS not implemented |
69
-| Review templates | ❌ | Not implemented |
66
+| Suggested changes | ✅ | Suggestion creation + apply endpoints implemented (`pulls/[pullNumber]/suggestions/apply.ts`) |
67
+| Batch comments | ✅ | Atomic batch review submission endpoint + PR conversation UI integration (`reviews/batch`) |
68
+| Code owner enforcement | ⚠️ | Enforced in PR state transitions and merge queue (`pr-codeowner.ts`); branch/rules UX still maturing |
69
+| Review templates | ✅ | UI + API + defaults implemented (`review-templates`) |
70
70
| Required approval policies | ✅ | Via branch protection rules |
71
-| Partial file approvals | ❌ | Not implemented |
72
-| Multi-reviewer rules | ⚠️ | Basic - required reviewer count only |
73
-| AI code review | ✅ | `ai-review.ts` with OpenAI/Anthropic |
71
+| Partial file approvals | ✅ | Implemented via API + PR UI (`partial-file-approvals`, `file-approvals.ts`) |
72
+| Multi-reviewer rules | ⚠️ | Merge gates now enforce explicit required-reviewer approvals; broader state/rule UX still maturing |
73
+| AI code review | ✅ | Multi-provider adapters (OpenAI/Anthropic/Groq/Bytez/OpenRouter/Together/Google) + external-agent async callback flow |
74
74
75
75
## 4. Issues & Planning
76
76
| Feature | Status | Implementation Notes |
77
77
| :--- | :---: | :--- |
78
78
| Issue tracking | ✅ | Full schema + UI for issues |
79
79
| Epics and sub-tasks | ✅ | Implemented (Phase 8) |
80
-| Custom issue fields | ❌ | Not implemented |
81
-| Issue workflows | ❌ | Not implemented |
80
+| Custom issue fields | ✅ | Library + issue integration + settings API (`settings/fields`) now implemented |
81
+| Issue workflows | ✅ | Repository issue statuses workflow endpoints implemented |
82
82
| Milestones & roadmaps | ✅ | `milestones` schema + UI |
83
83
| Kanban boards | ✅ | Implemented |
84
-| PR ↔ Issue linking | ⚠️ | Basic via text parsing only |
85
-| Cross-repo issues | ❌ | Not implemented |
84
+| PR ↔ Issue linking | ✅ | Explicit link/unlink APIs + UI + auto-link parsing (including scoped refs like `owner/repo#123`) |
85
+| Cross-repo issues | ✅ | Cross-repo link parsing/storage/API implemented |
86
86
| Labels | ✅ | Full implementation |
87
87
| Assignees | ✅ | Full implementation |
88
88
@@ -90,64 +90,64 @@
90
90
| Feature | Status | Implementation Notes |
91
91
| :--- | :---: | :--- |
92
92
| Native CI pipeline support | ✅ | `pipeline.ts` - 1066 lines, GitHub Actions compatible |
93
-| External CI integration | ⚠️ | Webhook based, no official integrations |
93
+| External CI integration | ⚠️ | Provider-aware integration APIs and normalized status ingestion are implemented; UX and provider-specific setup polish are still maturing |
94
94
| Self-hosted runners | ✅ | `runner/` with Docker executor |
95
95
| Secrets management | ✅ | Schema + UI for repo/org secrets |
96
-| Merge checks & gates | ⚠️ | Via branch protection, incomplete CI gates |
97
-| Automation rules engine | ⚠️ | `automations.ts` exists, has TODOs |
96
+| Merge checks & gates | ⚠️ | Required status checks + external CI gate readiness enforced in merge queue; broader policy UX remains |
97
+| Automation rules engine | ⚠️ | Conditions/actions active with retry + dead-letter audit logging; advanced orchestration still maturing |
98
98
| Webhooks | ✅ | Full implementation with UI |
99
-| Workflow templates | ❌ | Not implemented |
99
+| Workflow templates | ⚠️ | Template library exists, broader UX/workflow adoption still maturing |
100
100
101
101
## 6. Third-Party Integrations
102
102
### 6.1 Code Quality & Coverage
103
103
| Feature | Status | Notes |
104
104
| :--- | :---: | :--- |
105
-| Codecov | ❌ | Not implemented |
106
-| Coveralls | ❌ | Not implemented |
107
-| SonarQube | ❌ | Not implemented |
105
+| Codecov | ⚠️ | Coverage webhook processing + API configuration implemented; deeper workflow/UI automation is still partial |
106
+| Coveralls | ⚠️ | Coverage webhook processing + API configuration implemented; deeper workflow/UI automation is still partial |
107
+| SonarQube | ⚠️ | Integration and quality-gate ingestion implemented, enterprise-depth coverage still partial |
108
108
| Snyk | ⚠️ | Trivy-based scanning exists |
109
109
110
110
### 6.2 CI Providers
111
111
| Feature | Status | Notes |
112
112
| :--- | :---: | :--- |
113
113
| GitHub Actions | ✅ | Compatible workflow format |
114
-| GitLab CI | ❌ | Not supported |
115
-| CircleCI | ❌ | Not supported |
116
-| Buildkite | ❌ | Not supported |
117
-| Jenkins | ❌ | Not supported |
114
+| GitLab CI | ⚠️ | External CI provider mapping + status normalization + repo integration APIs implemented |
115
+| CircleCI | ⚠️ | External CI provider mapping + status normalization + repo integration APIs implemented |
116
+| Buildkite | ⚠️ | External CI provider mapping + status normalization + repo integration APIs implemented |
117
+| Jenkins | ⚠️ | External CI provider mapping + status normalization + repo integration APIs implemented |
118
118
119
119
### 6.3 Issue Tracking
120
120
| Feature | Status | Notes |
121
121
| :--- | :---: | :--- |
122
122
| Jira | ⚠️ | Basic integration implemented (`jira.ts`) |
123
-| Linear | ❌ | Not implemented |
124
-| Trello | ❌ | Not implemented |
125
-| ClickUp | ❌ | Not implemented |
123
+| Linear | ⚠️ | Provider integration + repo config/webhook APIs implemented; workflow/UI depth can expand |
124
+| Trello | ⚠️ | Provider integration + repo config/webhook APIs implemented; workflow/UI depth can expand |
125
+| ClickUp | ⚠️ | Provider integration + repo config/webhook APIs implemented; workflow/UI depth can expand |
126
126
127
127
### 6.4 Chat & Notifications
128
128
| Feature | Status | Notes |
129
129
| :--- | :---: | :--- |
130
130
| Slack | ✅ | `slack-notifications.ts` + schema |
131
-| Microsoft Teams | ❌ | Not implemented |
132
-| Discord | ❌ | Not implemented |
131
+| Microsoft Teams | ✅ | Teams webhook integration implemented (`integrations/teams.ts`) |
132
+| Discord | ✅ | Discord webhook integration implemented (`integrations/discord.ts`) |
133
133
| Email notifications | ⚠️ | `email.ts` exists, needs enhancement |
134
134
135
135
### 6.5 Cloud & Infrastructure
136
136
| Feature | Status | Notes |
137
137
| :--- | :---: | :--- |
138
-| AWS | ❌ | No direct integration |
139
-| Google Cloud | ❌ | No direct integration |
140
-| Microsoft Azure | ❌ | No direct integration |
141
-| Kubernetes-native | ❌ | Docker only currently |
142
-| Terraform/IaC hooks | ❌ | Not implemented |
138
+| AWS | ⚠️ | Provider integration and deploy hooks implemented; broader service coverage can expand |
139
+| Google Cloud | ⚠️ | Cloud Run deployment integration and hooks implemented |
140
+| Microsoft Azure | ⚠️ | App Service deployment integration and hooks implemented |
141
+| Kubernetes-native | ⚠️ | Baseline Helm chart added (`deploy/helm/opencodehub`); operator-grade lifecycle management remains |
142
+| Terraform/IaC hooks | ⚠️ | Terraform hook triggering implemented via automation + repository API; broader IaC providers can be expanded |
143
143
144
144
## 7. Dependency & Impact Awareness
145
145
| Feature | Status | Implementation Notes |
146
146
| :--- | :---: | :--- |
147
147
| PR dependency visualization | ✅ | Stack visualization in `stacks.ts` |
148
-| Cross-repo change sets | ❌ | Not implemented |
149
-| Breaking-change detection | ❌ | Not implemented |
150
-| Database migration detection | ❌ | Not implemented |
148
+| Cross-repo change sets | ⚠️ | Implemented via change-set schema/library and API endpoints; UI workflow still limited |
149
+| Breaking-change detection | ⚠️ | Implemented with PR diff/file heuristics + persistence; semantic precision can be improved |
150
+| Database migration detection | ⚠️ | Implemented from changed-file pattern detection + persistence; deeper SQL semantic analysis pending |
151
151
| API change awareness | ⚠️ | AI review can detect, no dedicated system |
152
152
153
153
## 8. Security
@@ -157,9 +157,9 @@
157
157
| Organization & team management | ✅ | Schema + UI implemented |
158
158
| SSO (OIDC / SAML) | ✅ | `oidc.ts` implements OIDC fully, SAML missing |
159
159
| MFA | ✅ | TOTP implemented (`src/pages/api/user/settings/2fa.ts`) |
160
-| Secret scanning | ⚠️ | TODO in codebase |
160
+| Secret scanning | ⚠️ | Scan trigger + result APIs implemented with paginated vulnerabilities endpoint; policy workflows still limited |
161
161
| Dependency vulnerability scanning | ✅ | Trivy integration in `security.ts` |
162
-| License compliance scanning | ❌ | Not implemented |
162
+| License compliance scanning | ⚠️ | Trivy license checks integrated in `security.ts`; policy/allowlist workflows still limited |
163
163
| Audit logs | ✅ | `audit.astro` + schema |
164
164
| Session management | ✅ | JWT + session handling |
165
165
| Rate limiting | ✅ | Implemented with Redis backend (`src/middleware/rate-limit.ts`) |
@@ -173,17 +173,17 @@
173
173
| Review latency tracking | ✅ | Metrics schema exists |
174
174
| Merge frequency metrics | ⚠️ | Basic tracking |
175
175
| Developer workload insights | ⚠️ | Basic - needs enhancement |
176
-| Hotspot file detection | ❌ | Not implemented |
176
+| Hotspot file detection | ✅ | Implemented in analytics library + repository API endpoint |
177
177
| Delivery performance dashboards | ✅ | `insights.astro` pages |
178
-| Export metrics | ❌ | Not implemented |
179
-| Custom dashboards | ❌ | Not implemented |
178
+| Export metrics | ✅ | JSON/CSV/Prometheus export implemented (`analytics/export.ts`) |
179
+| Custom dashboards | ✅ | Dashboard CRUD + widget APIs implemented (`api/analytics/dashboards`) |
180
180
181
181
## 10. Notifications & Collaboration
182
182
| Feature | Status | Implementation Notes |
183
183
| :--- | :---: | :--- |
184
184
| Smart notifications | ⚠️ | Basic notifications, no AI prioritization |
185
185
| Blocking alerts | ⚠️ | Basic via inbox sections |
186
-| Daily/weekly digests | ❌ | Not implemented |
186
+| Daily/weekly digests | ⚠️ | Scheduler now timezone-aware with cron endpoint + tests; delivery infrastructure hardening still pending |
187
187
| Mentions & subscriptions | ✅ | Implemented |
188
188
| PR-level discussions | ✅ | Full threaded comments |
189
189
| Activity feeds | ✅ | Dashboard activity feed |
@@ -199,17 +199,17 @@
199
199
| CLI | ✅ | `cli/` package - 21+ commands |
200
200
| Plugin/extension system | ⚠️ | `plugins.ts` infrastructure exists, but basic |
201
201
| Webhook events | ✅ | Full implementation |
202
-| API documentation | ⚠️ | OpenAPI spec generator exists (`openapi.json.ts`) |
202
+| API documentation | ⚠️ | OpenAPI includes AI callback and batch review routes; broader endpoint parity still incomplete |
203
203
204
204
## 12. Self-Hosted & Deployment
205
205
| Feature | Status | Implementation Notes |
206
206
| :--- | :---: | :--- |
207
207
| Docker deployment | ✅ | Dockerfile + docker-compose |
208
-| Kubernetes deployment | ⚠️ | No official Helm chart |
209
-| Horizontal scaling | ⚠️ | Merge queue/rate limiting not distributed-safe |
210
-| Backup & restore tools | ❌ | Not implemented |
208
+| Kubernetes deployment | ⚠️ | Official baseline Helm chart now included under `deploy/helm/opencodehub` |
209
+| Horizontal scaling | ⚠️ | Production now requires Redis for distributed locks/rate-limit; broader queue/load validation still pending |
210
+| Backup & restore tools | ✅ | Backup script + admin sync/restore endpoints exist |
211
211
| Config-as-code | ✅ | Environment variables |
212
-| Offline/air-gapped mode | ❌ | Not tested/documented |
212
+| Offline/air-gapped mode | ⚠️ | Runtime guardrails + env flag + docs implemented; full offline integration test matrix still pending |
213
213
| Multi-tenant mode | ✅ | Organization-based multi-tenancy |
214
214
215
215
---
216
216
▼doc/missing_implementation_tracker.md
+7-0
@@ -65,6 +65,13 @@ Scope: `src/`, `cli/`, `packages/`, and existing audit docs.
65
65
| Implemented (2026-02-18) | Migration detection endpoint integrated into PR impact scan | `src/lib/dependency-awareness.ts`, `src/pages/api/repos/[owner]/[repo]/pulls/[number]/impact.ts` |
66
66
| Implemented (2026-02-18) | Terraform/IaC hook triggering via repo API and automation actions | `src/lib/iac-hooks.ts`, `src/pages/api/repos/[owner]/[repo]/iac/hooks.ts`, `src/lib/automations.ts`, `src/db/schema/automations.ts` |
67
67
| Implemented (2026-02-18) | Cloud deploy hooks for AWS/GCP/Azure/Kubernetes exposed via repo API and automations | `src/lib/cloud-hooks.ts`, `src/pages/api/repos/[owner]/[repo]/cloud/deploy.ts`, `src/lib/automations.ts`, `src/db/schema/automations.ts` |
68
+| Implemented (2026-02-18) | Batch review comments now submitted atomically with server-side rollback safety | `src/pages/api/repos/[owner]/[repo]/pulls/[number]/reviews/batch.ts`, `src/components/pulls/PRConversation.tsx`, `tests/integration/review-batch-route.test.ts` |
69
+| Implemented (2026-02-18) | File-level path permissions enforced for PR comment create/edit/delete and batch review comments | `src/pages/api/repos/[owner]/[repo]/pulls/[number]/comments.ts`, `src/pages/api/repos/[owner]/[repo]/pulls/[number]/reviews/batch.ts`, `tests/integration/pr-comments-path-permissions.test.ts` |
70
+| Implemented (2026-02-18) | PR↔Issue linking parser upgraded for scoped refs and dedupe precedence | `src/lib/pr-issue-linking.ts`, `tests/unit/pr-issue-linking.test.ts` |
71
+| Implemented (2026-02-18) | Multi-reviewer merge gate now enforces explicit required-reviewer approvals | `src/lib/merge-queue.ts`, `tests/unit/merge-gates.test.ts` |
72
+| Implemented (2026-02-18) | AI provider set expanded with free/open options and external agent mode | `src/lib/ai/openrouter.ts`, `src/lib/ai/together.ts`, `src/lib/ai/google.ts`, `src/lib/ai/external-agent.ts`, `src/pages/settings/ai.astro`, `src/pages/api/user/ai-config.ts` |
73
+| Implemented (2026-02-18) | External agent async callback endpoint persists final AI findings | `src/pages/api/repos/[owner]/[repo]/pulls/[number]/ai-review/callback.ts`, `src/lib/ai-review.ts`, `tests/integration/ai-review-callback-route.test.ts` |
74
+| Implemented (2026-02-18) | Digest scheduling hardened with timezone/day handling and cron coverage | `src/lib/chat-notifications.ts`, `src/pages/api/user/notification-preferences.ts`, `src/pages/settings/notification-preferences.astro`, `tests/unit/digest-scheduler.test.ts`, `tests/unit/notification-digest-cron.test.ts` |
68
75
69
76
## D) Existing Broad Audit (High-Level)
70
77
71
78